
Christmas Adverts 2026: Why Morrisons’ 90-Second Goldilocks Beat John Lewis, and the Six-Minute Waitrose Film I’d Cut in Half
The best of the Christmas adverts 2026 has produced so far doesn’t have a pop star, a Dame or a three-minute running time. It has a pair of animatronic bears, a wonky tree and a Goldilocks who turns out to be the son’s new girlfriend. Morrisons’ 90-second film sits top of System1’s effectiveness rankings, level on stars with Sainsbury’s and M&S, while John Lewis, the brand that invented the modern Christmas advert as a national event, isn’t even in the top twelve.
In This Article
- The Christmas adverts 2026 scoreboard: 0.3 stars from first to twelfth
- Morrisons and the case for the 90-second advert
- John Lewis: a bad advert, or a loud minority?
- Six minutes of Keira Knightley is too much Keira Knightley
- Coca-Cola's third AI Christmas, and why the backlash hasn't hurt it
- The rest of the field, ranked by someone who's watched them too many times
- What this year says about the Christmas advert as a British ritual
That tells you most of what you need to know about this year.
I’ve watched every major release since the first teasers on 1 November, most of them twice, a couple of them more times than any adult should. My mum sent me the John Lewis one on WhatsApp before I’d had my first coffee on the 3rd, with the single comment “those kids”. She wasn’t the only one. But the gap between what people shout about on social media and what actually lands with viewers has rarely been wider, and that’s the story worth telling.
The Christmas adverts 2026 scoreboard: 0.3 stars from first to twelfth
System1 tests adverts on real viewers and scores them out of 5.9 stars for likely long-term brand effect, with a second “Spike” score for short-term sales impact. Its early leaderboard, published on 12 November, is unusually crowded at the top. Advanced Television reported that “just 0.3 Stars” separate first and twelfth place.
Eight adverts hit the maximum 5.9: Morrisons, Sainsbury’s, M&S, Aldi, Thatchers, Disney, Barbour’s Wallace & Gromit tie-in and the National Lottery. Coca-Cola, Lidl and Tesco follow on 5.7, with Waitrose on 5.6. John Lewis scored 5.6 on its own launch test, which, for what it’s worth, is its best result since Excitable Edgar in 2019.
Andrew Tindall at System1 summed up the leaders in one line: “If the early leaders tell us anything, it’s that Brits love an underdog.” He’s right, though I’d put it slightly differently. What the top of the table has in common isn’t underdogs so much as modesty. Small stakes, recognisable homes, food on a table, nobody being lectured about the true meaning of anything. The adverts that tried to say something big about giving, or love, or the season itself, tended to finish lower.
And there’s money riding on all this. The Advertising Association and WARC forecast UK ad spend of £14.0bn for the final quarter of 2026, up 8.2% on last year and a record for the festive quarter. A lot of that goes on the slots around Coronation Street, Bake Off and I’m a Celebrity, which is why the launch-night scheduling has become a story in itself.

Morrisons and the case for the 90-second advert
Morrisons’ “Christmas Made Just Right” went out at 9.15pm on Monday 9 November, simultaneously across ITV, Channel 4, Five and Sky. It’s a modern spin on Goldilocks. Mummy and Daddy Bear are getting ready for Baby Bear to bring his partner home for Christmas, Daddy Bear does a run to the Market Street counters, and the partner turns out to be Goldilocks. What she finds isn’t a perfect house. It’s a slightly wonky tree, decorations that don’t match and a chair that’s seen better days, and it’s warm, and that’s the point.
It works for reasons that are almost boringly simple. It’s 90 seconds long. The joke lands in the first half and the feeling lands in the second. The food is on screen without the camera fetishising it. And the animatronic bears have that slightly uncanny, slightly homemade look that makes you lean in rather than admire from a distance. LBC’s ranking gave it a perfect ten and said “this is the winner and it’s not even close”, which is about as unequivocal as an advert review gets.
I’d go further than LBC. Morrisons has made the advert John Lewis used to make. A small domestic story, a turn you don’t quite see coming, an ending that doesn’t need a soaring cover version to tell you how to feel. It’s the kind of thing you’d catch in an ad break during the soaps and still be thinking about while the kettle boils.
Sainsbury’s, level on stars and Spike with Morrisons, gets there by a different road. This is the BFG’s third year with the supermarket, and the 2026 film has him poorly in bed while a real Sainsbury’s colleague, Annie, drives a van of Taste the Difference into Giant Country with her sidekick Fred. They shake off the Greedy Giant by tipping sprouts across the road. LBC thought “the Sainsbury’s delivery team are the stars”, and I agree. Putting an actual shop-floor worker at the centre of a two-minute VFX film is a smart move, and a brave one, given how easily it could have looked like a corporate video.
John Lewis: a bad advert, or a loud minority?
Here’s the contrarian bit. The John Lewis advert is not the disaster the internet has decided it is.
The setup is this. Dame Kristin Scott Thomas plays Gloria, a glamorous gran who can’t work out what her restless grandchildren want, so she puts cash in their cards. Pickles, her vintage toy dog, voiced by Paul Whitehouse, comes to life, tells her “you can do better than cash” and drags her round London in a tuk-tuk on a last-minute gift hunt that ends, inevitably, at John Lewis. On Christmas morning the kids open an empty envelope and a key to Gloria’s “Gran Cave”. The soundtrack is Sam Fender’s cover of “You Can’t Always Get What You Want”, with profits from the single going to Action for Children. The tagline is “Don’t give up on giving”. It runs to three minutes and it’s the 20th John Lewis Christmas advert.
The reaction was brutal. A Mumsnet user called the grandchildren “absolute brats”. Piers Morgan described it as “possibly the worst advert I’ve ever seen for anything”. Creative Bloq said it “feels cold and clinical”, and LBC ranked it last of seven. Kantar said it lacked the emotional punch of previous years, while praising Scott Thomas’s performance.
But look at the numbers. System1 found 61% of viewers felt happy watching it, close to double the UK TV average, and its own team’s analysis in The Drum ran under the headline “They are loud, but only 6% really dislike the John Lewis Christmas ad”. About 15% of viewers recalled the children as rude. That’s a real number and it’s a real flaw. It isn’t the national revulsion you’d assume from a week of headlines. For context, the 2024 John Lewis film scored 4.6 and the 2025 one 5.1. This year’s is a clear step up on both.
So why the pile-on? Partly because the John Lewis advert is the only one people still treat as a cultural event, which means it gets reviewed like a film rather than watched like an advert. Partly because the “entitled kids” reading is easy to share in one sentence. And partly, I think, because the message really is muddled. The advert tells you cash is a lazy present, then rewards the kids with a secret room full of stuff, which, as Creative Bloq pointed out, rather suggests that spending money is the only way to get your grandchildren to like you. That’s a fair criticism of the script. It doesn’t make Kristin Scott Thomas, a talking dog and a tuk-tuk round London a bad watch.
My verdict: a decent advert with a confused moral, judged against a legacy it can’t live up to. Not the worst thing on telly this November. Not close.

Six minutes of Keira Knightley is too much Keira Knightley
If any advert this year deserves the kicking John Lewis got, it’s Waitrose’s.
“The Perfect Gift 2” is a sequel to last year’s romcom and it runs to six minutes, two longer than the original. Waitrose’s own marketing team has described it as the longest advert produced by a UK supermarket, as if that were a selling point. Keira Knightley is about to marry Hugo Bunty-Griffin, played by Alex Hassell, and Joe Wilkinson’s Phil races to the wedding with a homemade beef Wellington and a jar labelled “Marry Me Instead?”. Keira picks Phil, proposing with a ring made of cheese. It closes on Jennifer Rush’s “The Power of Love”.
There are good jokes in it. Wilkinson is very funny, as he always is, and the cheeseboard ring got an actual laugh out of me. It also picked up over 30,000 Instagram likes in its first four hours, so plenty of people are enjoying it. But it’s a 90-second idea stretched to fill a lunch break, and it shows. The middle drags. You can feel the brand wanting credit for making a short film, rather than making a short film that earns six minutes of anyone’s attention. LBC put it well: “It isn’t clever and too long at nearly six minutes.” System1 placed it twelfth, which is still a decent score, but bottom of the early leaderboard.
The length problem isn’t just a Waitrose problem. John Lewis is three minutes. M&S is about three. Disney’s is three minutes 22 seconds. Morrisons won with 90 seconds. I don’t think that’s a coincidence. Nobody watches a six-minute advert on ITV, so these long cuts live on YouTube and Instagram, where they compete with everything else on your phone. The brands are making films for an audience that mostly sees the 30-second edit at half nine on a Tuesday.
Coca-Cola’s third AI Christmas, and why the backlash hasn’t hurt it
Coca-Cola’s AI-generated “Holidays Are Coming” is back for a third year, and the reaction online has followed the familiar script: complaints about uncanny trucks, wobbly physics and the lack of human craft. And for a third year running, the testing data barely flinches. System1 scored the 2024 and 2025 versions at 5.9 stars and this one at 5.7, with 68% of viewers reporting they felt happy and contempt at 5%, which is the UK average.
Tindall’s piece in The Drum is the sharpest thing written about it: “That’s three years of backlash and three years of 5-Star ads.” He adds that “6% of millions is enough to fill every comment section in Britain”, and he’s right about that too.
I don’t like the Coke advert. It looks like a screensaver. But I’ve stopped believing the backlash will change anything, because it hasn’t, and the brands can see the same numbers System1 can. The more interesting response this year has come from the other direction. Several brands went loudly handmade: Aardman made the Barbour and Thatchers films, Prada went hand-drawn, Levi’s used stop-motion. Very, on the other hand, openly used a hybrid CGI and AI-assisted process for its flamingo film and nobody seems to have noticed or minded. The dividing line in 2026 isn’t AI against no AI. It’s whether the result looks like it was made with any care.

The rest of the field, ranked by someone who’s watched them too many times
Not every advert needs a full review. Here’s where I land on the others, best first.
M&S, “The Home of Christmas”. James Norton as a Santa who shaves off his beard and swaps the red suit for a jumper so he can experience Christmas incognito, with Lucy Punch as Mrs Claus and Katherine Jenkins singing “Heaven Is a Place on Earth”. It’s the first combined food, fashion and home campaign M&S has run since 2017, and it’s the most fun of the big-budget lot. LBC called it “perhaps the best use of a celebrity in any 2026 Christmas advert”. I’d agree. Norton is clearly in on the joke.
Disney, “The Invisible Horse”. A boy who thinks he’s too old for Christmas befriends a horse nobody else can see. Directed by Dougal Wilson, who directed several of the John Lewis classics, with a reworked “Oo-De-Lally” from Robin Hood. It’s the closest thing to an old-school John Lewis tearjerker this year, which is a bit awkward for John Lewis.
Aldi, Kevin the Carrot. Kevin’s family follow paw prints through the snow looking for Cauli Dog, who turns out to be asleep in a Christmas cracker. You know exactly what you’re getting with Kevin by now and it scored 5.9 anyway. Familiarity isn’t laziness when it works this reliably.
Argos, “Tales of Argos Past”. Richard Ayoade as a gift-dodging Scrooge, haunted by the Argos mascots. The idea is that Argos isn’t just a toy shop. Ayoade’s deadpan carries it.
Tesco, “The Wrong Address”. Anna Maxwell Martin sends her Christmas delivery to her old house hundreds of miles away and driver Roisin Conaty takes it on a road trip that becomes a school-friends reunion, soundtracked by The Police. Pleasant, well cast, and thoroughly mocked by actual Tesco drivers, who told The Grocer it showed “literally everything we are specifically forbidden from doing in one short clip”. That’s the best review any advert got this year.
Lidl, “Lidl Christmas Everybody”. Shaun Williamson and Chris Kamara go door to door with Lidl food to a reworked Slade. Exactly as daft as it sounds. Does the job.
Amazon, “Joy Delivered”. A woman stranded by a cancelled flight gets home by bus, boat and taxi, handing out her presents to the people who help along the way, to a cover of The Beatles’ “Golden Slumbers”. Beautifully shot and instantly forgettable.
Asda. Four 30-second films where a perfect Christmas scene descends into a rave, to a Martin Garrix remix. The Grinch has been retired. I can’t say I miss him, and I won’t miss these either.

What this year says about the Christmas advert as a British ritual
For about a decade, roughly from The Long Wait in 2011 to Excitable Edgar in 2019, the John Lewis launch worked like a TV premiere. People talked about it at work. Newspapers ran the “has John Lewis made you cry yet” pieces. It was, in a small way, part of the same cultural calendar as the Royal Variety Performance and the first big carol concerts of the season.
That’s gone, and 2026 is the year it became obvious. Twelve adverts within 0.3 stars of each other means there’s no longer one advert that defines the season. The audience has fragmented the same way TV viewing has, something we looked at in our piece on Netflix vs BBC viewing in 2026: nobody’s watching the same thing at the same time any more, so nothing can be the thing everyone watched. The brands have adapted. They launch on Instagram at 7am and treat the TV slot as a second wave. Morrisons is one of the few that still did a proper simultaneous broadcast roadblock, and it’s top of the table.
There’s a lesson in that, I think, and it’s the one the supermarkets have learnt faster than the department stores. A Christmas advert doesn’t need to be an event any more. It needs to be a nice 90 seconds in an ad break during Strictly season, something that makes you a bit warmer towards a shop you were going to go to anyway. Morrisons and Sainsbury’s understood that. Waitrose made a short film nobody asked for. John Lewis is still trying to make the advert everyone talks about, and found out the hard way that people do still talk about it, just not in the way it hoped.
There are still a few to come, including McDonald’s, which hadn’t released a UK Christmas film at the time of writing. But I’d be surprised if anything knocks a pair of animatronic bears off the top.
So which one has actually stuck with you, and has any of them changed where you’re doing your Christmas shop?




